HR Talks to: Noel Keeley, recently retired CEO of Musgrave

For our latest HR Talks, we are delighted to turn the spotlight on Noel Keeley, CEO of Musgrave, and a leader whose career journey offers a particularly interesting perspective for those working in HR. Moving from HR Director to CEO is not a route we see every day in the Irish market. Noel’s journey is a great opportunity to explore how a career in HR can provide a strong foundation for broader business leadership, the importance of commercial experience, and what it really takes to lead a business. With a career spanning senior HR, operational and commercial leadership, Noel has played an important role in the Musgrave story. As one of Ireland’s best-known family-owned businesses, Musgrave has a long heritage in food retail and wholesale, supporting independent retailers and serving communities across the country. We were keen to hear more about Noel’s own journey, the lessons he has learned along the way, and what advice he would share with HR professionals who aspire to have a seat at the very top table.

From HR Director to CEO

You began at Musgrave as Group HR Director before moving into operational leadership and ultimately becoming CEO. Did you always have ambitions to move beyond HR, or did that opportunity develop more organically?

It was much more organic than planned. I was always ambitious and curious, but I never had a career plan that said, “I want to be a CEO.” My career has been quite unconventional. I spent ten years in northern Canada in roles spanning HR, finance, corporate affairs and healthcare management, returned to Ireland to join UCC as Vice President for HR, and then joined Musgrave as Group HR Director in 2005.  The pivotal move was into running Musgrave Wholesale Partners. Suddenly I wasn’t advising the person accountable for the result. I was the person accountable for the result. From there I took responsibility for Northern Ireland and ultimately became Group CEO.  Looking back, I didn’t chase titles. I kept taking opportunities that stretched me. That probably made the biggest difference to my career.

How did HR shape you as a CEO?

Profoundly. HR taught me that businesses don’t execute strategies. People do. It gave me an understanding of culture, talent and organisational dynamics, but I also realised that HR expertise alone wouldn’t equip me to run a business. I needed to understand customers, competitors, operations, finance and how the organisation actually made money. So I never tried to leave HR behind. I added commercial and operational experience to it. That combination became one of my greatest strengths as a CEO.

Moving from HR into commercial leadership

What did you need to learn along the way, and how important was gaining hands-on commercial experience?

It was critical. The biggest change was accountability. As a functional leader you can recommend a course of action. When you run a business, you make the decision and live with the consequences. Running Musgrave Wholesale Partners gave me responsibility for the P&L, customers, operations, investment and overall business performance. I later took responsibility for Northern Ireland, where we undertook a significant turnaround.  It also taught me to stay close to customers and the operation. A spreadsheet will tell you what happened. The people closest to the customer will often tell you why.

What makes an effective CEO?

What distinguishes a strong functional leader from someone who can lead an entire organisation?

The biggest difference is learning to think about the whole enterprise rather than the part you know best. A CEO has to keep asking, “What is the right answer for the business?” That requires clarity, judgement and sometimes difficult choices. I also learned that you don’t need to be the smartest person in every room. In fact, if you consistently are, you’ve probably got the wrong people in the room. Good leadership is about surrounding yourself with talented people, asking good questions, listening carefully, making decisions and accepting responsibility for the outcome.

The Musgrave story

What has been fundamental to Musgrave’s success, and how do you balance its heritage with the need to evolve?

Musgrave’s longevity comes from a powerful combination of values and adaptability. Values such as honesty, hard work, achievement, long-term relationships and not being greedy have endured through generations. But longevity doesn’t come from resisting change. Every generation has had to reinvent aspects of the business. For me, the leadership challenge is knowing what should change and what should never change. Technology, consumer behaviour and business models will continually evolve. Trust, entrepreneurship, integrity and strong relationships remain enormously valuable.

Culture and performance in retail

Can you share an example of where getting the people piece right made a real difference?

Covid is the best and clearest example. I became CEO in January 2020 and within weeks we faced circumstances none of us had experienced before. Retail demand surged, foodservice was severely disrupted and our supply chain came under enormous pressure.  There was no playbook. What mattered was how people responded: moving quickly, working across boundaries and taking personal responsibility. It reinforced something I’ve always believed: culture is built in the good times and revealed in the difficult ones. Culture isn’t the soft side of business. At moments like that, it becomes one of your most important operating assets.

HR in the boardroom

What separates an HR Director who is excellent at leading their function from one who genuinely influences business strategy?

A great HR Director thinks of themselves as a business leader first and an HR specialist second. Understand the P&L. Know the customers and competitors. Understand where value is created and destroyed and connect people decisions directly to business outcomes. You also need a point of view. Executive influence isn’t earned by agreeing with everybody. My advice to HR leaders is to get out of HR regularly. Spend time with customers and operations. Get involved in acquisitions, investment decisions or a turnaround. You earn influence by helping solve business problems, not by insisting HR deserves a seat at the table.

The future of Irish retail

What do you see as the biggest opportunities and challenges over the coming years?

For me, the defining issue is the pace of change. Consumers increasingly expect value, quality and convenience together. At the same time, technology, data and AI are advancing rapidly. The interesting question isn’t whether a company can say it “uses AI”. It’s whether technology helps it make better decisions, serve customers better, improve productivity and remove unnecessary complexity. The winners won’t necessarily be the businesses with the most technology. They’ll be those that combine technology with commercial judgement, talented people and the ability to execute at pace.

Career advice for aspiring HR leaders

If an ambitious HR Director came to you today with aspirations of becoming a CEO, what advice would you give them?

I’d give them five pieces of advice.

  • Be excellent at the job you’re doing now.
  • Learn how your business makes money.
  • Seek real accountability. Run something, own a P&L, lead a turnaround or take responsibility for customers.
  • Make yourself uncomfortable. Some of my best career opportunities were roles I wasn’t completely certain I was ready for.
  • And finally, stay curious.

If I were starting again, I might seek direct commercial experience a little earlier. But I wouldn’t change the unconventional nature of my career. I started in HR and ultimately had the privilege of becoming CEO of Musgrave. The lesson I take from that is that where you start your career doesn’t have to determine where you finish it.

And if I were to leave an ambitious HR leader with one final thought, it would be this:

Don’t build your career around the job you ultimately want. Build the breadth, judgement and experience that will allow you to do that job well if the opportunity comes.

Noel, thank you for sharing your story with HR Talks. Your journey is a valuable reminder of the contribution HR leaders can make beyond their own function, and of the importance of curiosity, commercial understanding, and a willingness to take on new challenges. HR Talks is brought to you by HR Search, part of Vertical Markets Group, where we explore the people, ideas and leadership experiences shaping the world of work. If your organisation is thinking about how to attract and retain senior HR talent in an increasingly complex environment, get in touch with the HR Search team. For more interviews and HR insights take a look here.

Insights